Tuesday, November 17, 2026

 







Part I, Installment 5

NOW I'M REALLY MAD


I may be old fashioned, but I’ve always figured that if someone puts a certain price on something—say, a bag of candy corn—and that price is 79 cents, then it’s really not cool for the seller to raise the price just as you're about to pay him for it. And it seems especially uncool if you’ve already offered
"Sure, I said it was 79 cents—but now
that I know you want it, it's more. Gotcha!"
more than what he was asking. Our offer for 707 Cragmont had already exceeded the seller's original asking price of $795,000, and the broker's response had been to jack the price up to $825,000. 

I didn't like this at all. Still, the real estate market being as red hot as it was, and having been told—probably falsely— that there was another interested buyer in the running, we compromised and met her halfway with a new higher offer of $812,000.

Which was rejected.

I’m a pretty easygoing person, but what happened after that was—I got really mad. In light of the fact that this swaybacked old dump had a whole galaxy of structural problems, I found it unspeakably audacious for the broker to come back with a counteroffer $30,000 higher than her original asking price. I got so mad, in fact, that I decided to get even in the only way my tiny architect brain could think of: I hired a soil engineer—a person well versed in landslide problems, foundation settlement, and the like— to give me a written opinion on the property. 

William K. Langbehn was a highly respected geotechnical engineer, and well versed in the landslides that plagued the hills of North Berkeley. As I expected, his review of the property came back stating that 707 Cragmont Avenue was “fully engaged” in an already infamous Berkeley hills geological feature known as the Southampton Slide. What's more, he concluded that the house was so damaged that it required foundation replacement, adding that "projects of this nature almost always runs into six figures."

My soil engineer's review letter,
faxed to my office in March 2006.
The operative sentence read, "The
foundation damage...is now severe
enough that foundation replace-
 ment is required."
I asked Monica Wong to pass this written opinion on to the seller’s broker, and to let her know we were requesting foundation replacement cost estimates from several contractors and would make a counteroffer when we had that information. A week later, I received the first itemized cost estimate from a contractor colleague, showing that a new foundation would run well north of $200,000. A second contractor's estimate essentially confirmed that cost range.

Neither the soil engineer’s letter nor the two cost estimates went over well with the seller’s broker. She called Monica and chewed her out in a fury. Why? Because, by law, the soil engineer’s letter would now have to be included in the seller’s disclosures, where any future prospective buyer would see them. The broker was livid that her gravy train had been derailed. As for me, I thought it served her right, and to make the point, we lowered our offer to $770,000—$25,000 less than the original asking price.

Which the buyers accepted.

But if ever I thought landing the house for that price was a bargain, time would prove me very wrong—as you’ll see soon enough. 


Next time: Be careful what you wish for.



No comments:

Post a Comment